'The Children Were Fine'
  • Home
  • About Us
  • 'The Children Were Fine'
    • Background
    • Research
    • Our Knowledge Base
    • The Full Paper
    • Our Recommendations
    • Feedback From The Field >
      • Feedback From Foster Carers & Adoptive Parents
      • Feedback From Professionals
  • Latest News
  • Suggested Reading
  • Contact

Feedback from IRO: Sylvia Smith, UK

23/2/2015

 
​In February 2015, we received the following email from an Independent Reviewing Officer in the UK:
​Dear Sophie,

Just to let you have some positive feedback.  I shared your paper with my colleagues and the content really resonated with their experiences.  The paper was timely…  I wish to thank both you and Lynne for sharing. 

Kind Regards
Sylvia Smith
Independent Reviewing Officer (Children's Services)

Foster Carer Feedback: Syd and Elaine

16/2/2015

 
​In February 2015, we received an email from Syd and Elaine, experienced foster carers in the UK, telling us: "Your recent paper 'The Children Were Fine' has put into words what we all feel instinctively, and has been of great help to us."

They describe an example of one of their foster children who was recently moved into adoption in a way they had felt was very distressing to themselves and to the child. The child found the parting very upsetting, and when the foster carers visited, her attempts to engage with them was clearly deeply upsetting for her new adoptive mother. 

"The mum tried to keep the child separate from us, not very successfully however, as the child's insisted on being picked up, held and interacting with each of us."

After this, they describe how their request for a second visit was refused. The child’s social worker supported this decision. These foster carers felt that the system was working against the best interests of the child and support our attempt to challenge these procedures:
 
"You are putting the child first - something we don't always see in the complex world of Social Work, Sheriff's Courts, Children's Hearings, Parental Human Rights, budgets and performance targets."

Please find their full email below (printed with Syd and Elaine's permission:
​Hello Sophie,

My wife and I have been local authority foster carers for 8 years.
During October, we moved on a child who had been with us from 17 hours old to 2 yrs and 2 months.  We loved her like our own.
The move did not go well.  Over the course of 10 days she was introduced to the new Mum and Dad, spent time with them at our home then their home, and then watched us leave her.
It was very difficult emotionally, she cried and hung on to my wife as we left her after the final visit.
The new parents did not keep us in touch with her progress - (Our Social Worker told us the child was doing fine!!) - and only reluctantly agreed to us seeing her again 3 weeks after the handover - but only then on "neutral territory."
During that visit, the mum tried to keep the child separate from us, not very successfully however, as the child insisted on being picked up, held and interacting with each of us.
We had explained to them during the early stages of the importance of allowing her to see us after the handover, to withdraw slowly so that she didn't think all important adults left her with strangers and didn't care about her. However, the Mum clearly had become threatened by the child's obvious affection for us and had decided a clean break was better for everybody.  Our request for a second visit was refused, this decision being supported by the parents' Social Worker.
We know this was a mistake and experience tells us that long term damage to the adoptive parent/child relationship is a strong possibility.

We have shared our distress with other, very experienced, foster carers who have all had similar unsatisfactory, (and much worse), outcomes.
We all want to get together, to pool our ideas and then to approach our local authority with the aim of changing the standard operating procedure, (developed 20 years ago when children moved on after 6 to 8 months?), to meet the needs of today, when due to the strong representation of parents rights in the courts, the children are with the foster carer for 2 to 3 years and attachments are therefore much stronger.

Your recent paper "The children were fine" has put into words what we all feel instinctively, and has been of great help to us.

Finally, can we, as a group of concerned Foster Carers, thank you for the lead you have taken in this area.  You are putting the child first - something we don't always see in the complex world of Social Work, Sheriff's Courts, Children's Hearings, Parental Human Rights, budgets and performance targets.

Regards

Syd and Elaine Gardiner
16/2/15

'The Children Were Fine' referenced in Childmyths blog

6/2/2015

 
Our 'The Children Were Fine' paper was referenced in Jean Mercer's Childmyths blog: An Observable Problem for Adopted Children, and Why We Need Not Look for a "Primal Wound":

A recent article in the journal Adoption & Fostering is very relevant to that need (Boswell, S., & Cudmore, L. (2014). “The children were fine”: Acknowledging complex feelings in the move from foster care into adoption. A & F, 38, 5-21). The authors, two British child psychotherapists in the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service,  focused on what happens as children who have been fostered move into adoptive homes. Boswell and Cudmore point out that “Adoption involves huge long-term gains for children, but leaving the care of their previous home will also involve a major loss”--  the loss of a foster parent, who may be the only caregiver a young child can remember, and who is very likely to be the only stable caregiver he or she has known.

Click here to read Jean Mercer's full blog entry.

    Latest News

    This topic has been gaining momentum in recent months. This news section includes some examples of recent coverage.

    ​Please share any news, opinions or experiences you have and we will add them to this section so we can disseminate them and keep up the momentum.

    Archives

    April 2018
    March 2018
    September 2017
    April 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    July 2014
    March 2014
    November 2013

    Categories

    All
    Advisory Panels
    Conferences & Presentations
    Feedback From Foster Carers And Adoptive Parents
    Feedback From Professionals
    Publications & Media Coverage
    Related Research
    Video Seminars

    RSS Feed

Background
Research
​Our Knowledge Base
The Full Paper
Our Recommendations
​Feedback From The Field
info@thechildrenwerefine.co.uk

Website by lizhawkins.co.uk